Skip to content

Your cart is empty

Continue shopping

Have an account?

Log in to check out faster.

Your cart

Loading...

Estimated total

$0.00 USD

Taxes, discounts and shipping calculated at checkout.
  • All Things Bridal
    • All Things Bridal
    • Custom CAD Jewelry Design
    • Made To Order Engagement Rings
    • Wedding Bands
    • Lab Grown Diamonds
    • Diamond Finder
  • Gemstone Jewelry
    • Gemstone Rings
    • Gemstone Pendant Necklaces
    • Gemstone Earrings
    • Gemstone Bracelets
    • FREE Gemstones
  • Fashion
    • Fashion Necklaces
    • Fashion Earrings
    • Fashion Rings
    • Fashion Bracelets
    • Hoop Earrings
    • Stud Earrings
  • Gifts
    • Personalized Jewelry
  • Collections
    • The Alhambra Collection
    • The CFD Pearl Collection
    • The Timeless Tennis Collection
    • The CFD Estate Collection
    • CFD Signature Custom Designs
    • Crosses and Stars
  • Men's
    • Chain Necklaces
    • The CFD Luxury Watch Collection
    • Men's Ready to Wear Collection
    • Men's Made To Order Wedding Bands
    • Malo Wedding Bands
    • Mardini Wedding Bands
    • Online Band Builder
  • Jewelry Repairs
    • Ring Resizing
    • Rhodium Plating
    • Stone Replacement
    • Chain Repairs
    • Complimentary Jewelry Inspection
  • More
    • Contact Us
    • Apply For Financing
    • Cash For Gold
    • Jewelry Appraisal Services
    • Meet The Team
    • Return Policy
Log in
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • YouTube
Logo with large CD letters and text Christopher Fine Diamonds in black on a white background.
  • All Things Bridal
    • All Things Bridal
    • Custom CAD Jewelry Design
    • Made To Order Engagement Rings
    • Wedding Bands
    • Lab Grown Diamonds
    • Diamond Finder
  • Gemstone Jewelry
    • Gemstone Rings
    • Gemstone Pendant Necklaces
    • Gemstone Earrings
    • Gemstone Bracelets
    • FREE Gemstones
  • Fashion
    • Fashion Necklaces
    • Fashion Earrings
    • Fashion Rings
    • Fashion Bracelets
    • Hoop Earrings
    • Stud Earrings
  • Gifts
    • Personalized Jewelry
  • Collections
    • The Alhambra Collection
    • The CFD Pearl Collection
    • The Timeless Tennis Collection
    • The CFD Estate Collection
    • CFD Signature Custom Designs
    • Crosses and Stars
  • Men's
    • Chain Necklaces
    • The CFD Luxury Watch Collection
    • Men's Ready to Wear Collection
    • Men's Made To Order Wedding Bands
    • Malo Wedding Bands
    • Mardini Wedding Bands
    • Online Band Builder
  • Jewelry Repairs
    • Ring Resizing
    • Rhodium Plating
    • Stone Replacement
    • Chain Repairs
    • Complimentary Jewelry Inspection
  • More
    • Contact Us
    • Apply For Financing
    • Cash For Gold
    • Jewelry Appraisal Services
    • Meet The Team
    • Return Policy
Log in Cart

Personalized Jewelry Gifts Under $500

Discover meaningful personalized gifts under $500—custom jewelry crafted for heartfelt moments, with options to search by color, design type, nameplates, initials, numerals, and inspiring words like faith, hope, and love.

Filter:

Price
The highest price is $499.98 Reset
$
$
Design Phrase
0 selected
Reset
Design Phrase
Initials
0 selected
Reset
Initials
Metal Color
0 selected
Reset
Metal Color
Jewelry type
0 selected Match all
Reset
Jewelry type
Remove all

866 products

Filter and sort Filter

Filter and sort

Filter

866 products

Price

The highest price is $499.98

$
$
Clear
Design Phrase
Clear
Initials
Clear
Metal Color
Clear
Jewelry type
Clear
Remove all
Remove all

866 products

  • 14K WHITE GOTHIC INITIAL Q EARRING

    14K WHITE GOTHIC INITIAL Q EARRING

    14K WHITE GOTHIC INITIAL Q EARRING

    Regular price $365.40 USD
    Regular price Sale price $365.40 USD
    Unit price /  per 
  • 14K WHITE GOTHIC INITIAL P EARRING

    14K WHITE GOTHIC INITIAL P EARRING

    14K WHITE GOTHIC INITIAL P EARRING

    Regular price $446.66 USD
    Regular price Sale price $446.66 USD
    Unit price /  per 
  • 14K WHITE GOTHIC INITIAL O EARRING

    14K WHITE GOTHIC INITIAL O EARRING

    14K WHITE GOTHIC INITIAL O EARRING

    Regular price $495.37 USD
    Regular price Sale price $495.37 USD
    Unit price /  per 
  • 14K WHITE GOTHIC INITIAL N EARRING

    14K WHITE GOTHIC INITIAL N EARRING

    14K WHITE GOTHIC INITIAL N EARRING

    Regular price $395.93 USD
    Regular price Sale price $395.93 USD
    Unit price /  per 
  • 14K WHITE GOTHIC INITIAL L EARRING

    14K WHITE GOTHIC INITIAL L EARRING

    14K WHITE GOTHIC INITIAL L EARRING

    Regular price $283.05 USD
    Regular price Sale price $283.05 USD
    Unit price /  per 
  • 14K WHITE GOTHIC INITIAL L CHARM/PENDANT

    14K WHITE GOTHIC INITIAL L CHARM/PENDANT

    14K WHITE GOTHIC INITIAL L CHARM/PENDANT

    Regular price $417.98 USD
    Regular price Sale price $417.98 USD
    Unit price /  per 
  • 14K WHITE GOTHIC INITIAL K EARRING

    14K WHITE GOTHIC INITIAL K EARRING

    14K WHITE GOTHIC INITIAL K EARRING

    Regular price $337.80 USD
    Regular price Sale price $337.80 USD
    Unit price /  per 
  • 14K WHITE GOTHIC INITIAL K CHARM/PENDANT

    14K WHITE GOTHIC INITIAL K CHARM/PENDANT

    14K WHITE GOTHIC INITIAL K CHARM/PENDANT

    Regular price $488.71 USD
    Regular price Sale price $488.71 USD
    Unit price /  per 
  • 14K WHITE GOTHIC INITIAL J CHARM/PENDANT

    14K WHITE GOTHIC INITIAL J CHARM/PENDANT

    14K WHITE GOTHIC INITIAL J CHARM/PENDANT

    Regular price $363.51 USD
    Regular price Sale price $363.51 USD
    Unit price /  per 
  • 14K WHITE GOTHIC INITIAL I EARRING

    14K WHITE GOTHIC INITIAL I EARRING

    14K WHITE GOTHIC INITIAL I EARRING

    Regular price $308.50 USD
    Regular price Sale price $308.50 USD
    Unit price /  per 
  • 14K WHITE GOTHIC INITIAL I CHARM/PENDANT

    14K WHITE GOTHIC INITIAL I CHARM/PENDANT

    14K WHITE GOTHIC INITIAL I CHARM/PENDANT

    Regular price $380.53 USD
    Regular price Sale price $380.53 USD
    Unit price /  per 
  • 14K WHITE GOTHIC INITIAL H EARRING

    14K WHITE GOTHIC INITIAL H EARRING

    14K WHITE GOTHIC INITIAL H EARRING

    Regular price $336.95 USD
    Regular price Sale price $336.95 USD
    Unit price /  per 
  • 1
  • …
  • 41
  • 42
  • 43
  • 44
  • 45
  • …
  • 73

Shop

  • Engagement Rings
  • Wedding Bands
  • Men's Jewelry
  • Fashion Jewelry
  • Gemstone Jewelry
  • Pearl Jewelry
  • Timeless Tennis Collection
  • Luxury Watches

Services

  • Fine Jewelry Repairs
  • Ring Resizing
  • Stone Replacement
  • Jewelry Appraisals
  • Chain Repairs
  • Clasp Repairs
  • Pearl Restringing
  • Jewelry Inspections
  • Rhodium Plating
  • Jewelry Financing

More

  • Contact Us
  • Our Blog
  • Meet the Team
  • Book With Us
  • Sell Your Jewelry
  • Return Policy
  • Lifetime Warranty

Let's be social

Instagram icon
YouTube icon
TikTok icon

Hours of Operation:

Sunday: CLOSED
Monday: CLOSED
Tuesday: 10AM - 6PM
Wednesday: 10AM - 6PM

Thursday: 10AM - 6PM

Friday: 10AM - 6PM

Saturday: 10AM - 5PM

  • American Express
  • Apple Pay
  • Diners Club
  • Discover
  • Google Pay
  • Mastercard
  • PayPal
  • Shop Pay
  • Venmo
  • Visa

© 2025, Christopher Fine Diamonds

  • Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
  • Opens in a new window.
Powered by Omni Themes